SCS Engineers

November 10, 2026

The Ninth Circuit’s November 9, 2026, opinion preserves California’s ability to require large companies to disclose operational greenhouse gas emissions while holding that Scope 3 value-chain emissions and climate-related financial risk disclosures likely violate the First Amendment. The practical distinction matters most for businesses with substantial direct emissions, significant purchased energy use, or complex supplier networks. This is a preliminary-injunction decision, not a final judgment resolving all challenges to California’s climate disclosure laws.

What the Decision Preserves—and Puts on Hold

SB 253 applies to companies doing business in California with annual revenue exceeding $1 billion and requires public disclosure of Scope 1,2, and 3 emissions. CARB’s November 10, 2026, deadline for first-year Scope 1 and Scope 2 reporting remained in effect. For companies that report on a calendar-year basis, the filing covers 2025 emissions. Scope 3 reporting was scheduled to begin in 2027. The court affirmed the denial of preliminary relief for Scope 1 and Scope 2 reporting (emissions from owned or controlled sources and purchased electricity, steam, heating, and cooling). It reversed the denial of preliminary relief for Scope 3 reporting (upstream and downstream emissions). The district court must determine whether the Scope 3 provisions can be severed from the remainder.

Under the decision summarized above, reporting depends on company size and emissions category, not industry:

  • Companies doing business in California with annual revenue exceeding $1 billion: SB 253’s Scope 1 reporting (direct emissions from owned or controlled operations) and Scope 2 reporting (emissions from purchased energy) remain unchanged.
  • Those same companies: Scope 3 reporting (upstream and downstream value-chain emissions) is subject to preliminary relief, with severability still pending before the district court.
  • Companies with annual revenue exceeding $500 million: SB 261’s climate-related financial-risk reports are subject to preliminary relief.

Importantly, this is a preliminary-injunction decision, not a final judgment striking Scope 3 reporting from California law. Reporting deadlines and implementation need confirmation; separate reporting obligations may still apply.

Implications for Operational Emissions Reporting and Supply Chains

Energy, industrial manufacturing, and transportation businesses face particularly significant continuing disclosure exposure because the surviving categories encompass fuel combustion and purchased energy. For covered companies, the central task remains assembling reliable operational emissions inventories, not assuming litigation eliminates reporting obligations. The opinion describes reporting under standardized Greenhouse Gas Protocol methodologies and independent third-party assurance. Those requirements emphasize internal records, organizational boundaries, calculation methods, and verifiable data supporting public disclosures.

Waste management and environmental infrastructure businesses also warrant attention when covered operations own or control emission sources, operate vehicle fleets, or purchase substantial energy. Their relevance follows from the scope definitions; the court does not specifically identify waste facilities or rank their compliance burdens. For these businesses, the decision distinguishes reporting on controlled operations from reporting on independent customers, contractors, and suppliers. It does not exempt environmental services or eliminate separate emissions regulations.

Agriculture, food processing, retail, and consumer-products businesses face a distinct exposure: potentially extensive supplier and customer networks. The ruling offers meaningful prospective relief from California’s Scope 3 mandate, which would require covered companies to collect third-party emissions data or use estimates. Agricultural associations are among the challengers. Smaller suppliers below SB 253’s revenue threshold are not automatically direct reporting entities, but the Scope 3 dispute matters because covered customers could otherwise seek information across their supply chains.

Construction, real estate, and technology businesses illustrate why purchased energy still is important even when direct fuel emissions are not the dominant reporting category. Covered companies must distinguish energy consumed in their own operations from emissions associated with independent value-chain participants. The court’s reasoning supports disclosure of internally documented operational information while rejecting the wider mandate’s justification. However, the opinion provides no sector-specific cost estimates, emissions comparisons, or evidence showing which individual companies will face the greatest burden.

Preliminary Relief for Climate-Risk Reporting

Financial services and other covered businesses receive broader preliminary relief under SB 261, which applies to businesses with annual revenue exceeding $500 million. The law requires biennial public reports on climate-related financial risks and adaptation measures. The majority concluded that mandated assessments of future conditions, strategy, governance, and competing priorities compel noncommercial speech and fail strict scrutiny. Separately, investors, lenders, and insurers remain relevant users of operational emissions information: the court linked those disclosures to risk assessment, profitability, and capital transactions.

What Covered Businesses Should Do Next

Companies subject to SB 253 should prepare for the next Scope 1 and Scope 2 reporting cycle by closing data gaps, documenting calculation methods, and organizing records for potential limited assurance. CARB is still developing its rules for 2027 and later reporting. While the case proceeds, companies can reassess work undertaken solely to comply with California’s Scope 3 and SB 261 disclosure requirements. The district court still needs to decide whether the Scope 3 requirement can be separated from the rest of SB 253.

Separate reporting rules may still require companies to quantify and disclose Scope 3 emissions. Examples include covered entities in Australia under AASB S2 and companies in EU member states such as France and Germany that are subject to the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive and applicable European Sustainability Reporting Standards. Applicability depends on the entity, the reporting year, and any available transition relief.

Companies participating in voluntary disclosure programs should check whether independent verification is required or requested, which emissions it should cover, and when it is needed. SCS Engineers can help companies develop or update their Scope 1, Scope 2, and Scope 3 greenhouse gas inventories and prepare for verification. SCS Engineers can also independently verify inventories it did not prepare, subject to applicable independence requirements.

 

Climate Change, Emissions Reporting, and Sustainability Resources:

  • Does my company have to report, and how do the revenue thresholds and “doing business in California” requirements apply?
  • What must we report now, and by when, given the different treatment of Scope 1, Scope 2, Scope 3, and climate-risk disclosures?
  • Can we pause preparations for Scope 3 and climate-risk reporting, or should we continue because of pending litigation and other reporting obligations?

 

 

 

 

Posted by Diane Samuels at 5:34 pm

November 9, 2026

Flooded underground mines may offer a new cooling resource for data centers, with feasibility depending on water quality, thermal capacity, and site conditions.

 

Cooling systems are essential to preserving reliable data center operations, but they can require significant amounts of electricity and water, particularly at large facilities. In some regions, competition for available water resources and limitations on existing infrastructure are creating additional challenges for developers. As a result, the industry is increasingly exploring alternative cooling technologies that can reduce operating costs, conserve water, and provide sustained reliability.

Flooded underground mines, once considered liabilities, may afford valuable hydro-geothermal infrastructure and sustainable liquid cooling for the rapidly expanding data center industry. With a specialized technical evaluation, these sites could provide an alternative cooling solution while creating new opportunities for mine owners and surrounding communities.

Extracting New Value from Existing Resources for Data Centers

This latent resource constitutes a vast network found throughout the United States. Many former coal, limestone, and other underground mining operations are naturally flooded after mining activities cease. These “wet” mines can contain substantial volumes of groundwater, or pools, that maintain relatively stable temperatures throughout the year.

By using engineered heat exchange systems, data centers may be able to transfer excess heat into underground mine pools rather than relying entirely on conventional cooling towers or mechanical refrigeration. Depending on site conditions and system design, this approach could reduce freshwater consumption, lower energy requirements, and provide a beneficial use for existing underground infrastructure that might otherwise remain unused.

The concept is already gaining attention. Iron Mountain’s underground data center facility in Pennsylvania shows the potential of using underground water resources to support data center cooling, while projects in Virginia are evaluating the feasibility of using flooded coal mines as thermal resources for proposed data center developments.

Innovative applications, such as Iron Mountain, highlight an emerging opportunity to repurpose former mining operations to support modern infrastructure. However, not every flooded mine will be suitable.

Environmental engineers and hydrogeologists, like SCS, evaluate factors such as groundwater availability, mine geometry, water chemistry, hydraulic connectivity, geological stability, and the surrounding rock and groundwater system’s ability to absorb and dissipate heat. Understanding these underground conditions is critical to determining whether flooded mines can provide a technically feasible, economically practical, and sustainable cooling solution.

Evaluating Mine Water Cooling Potential

SCS Engineers’ mining team is uniquely positioned to help municipalities, data center developers, mine owners, and energy providers assess these opportunities. Our experience in mining, geology, hydrogeology, subsurface characterization, groundwater modeling, drilling, and water management enables us to support investigating projects from initial feasibility through implementation.

Professionals at SCS Engineers recommend starting with an evaluation that covers:

  • Mine conditions and groundwater availability: Assessing flooded mine workings, geological stability, water volumes, and hydraulic connectivity.
  • Thermal capacity and sustainability: Evaluating whether mine systems can support long-term cooling demands.
  • Water quality and regulatory requirements: Determining potential treatment, permitting, and environmental aspects.
  • Infrastructure and implementation: Supporting well design, pumping systems, construction, and long-term monitoring.

To assess the potential of this sustainable solution, the evaluation results provide detailed intelligence on underground conditions, available water, and long-term thermal performance, which is essential to guide decision-making and infrastructure investment.

 

If you are interested in bridging the gap between underground mine resources and modern data center infrastructure, please contact the SCS team.

 

Additional Mining and Data Center Resources: 

 

 

Posted by Diane Samuels at 6:00 am

November 2, 2026

SCS Engineers is heading to Boston for the Society of Women Engineers’ WE26 Conference & Career Fair, November 5–7.

WE26 brings together students, professionals, recruiters and industry leaders for professional development, networking and conversations about the future of engineering and technology. Visit booth 13021 to meet our recruiting team, explore career and internship opportunities and learn how SCS professionals use their technical expertise to solve environmental and engineering challenges for clients and communities.

Whether you are beginning your career or looking for your next opportunity, we look forward to learning about your interests and sharing what it is like to grow with a 100% employee-owned firm. Stop by our booth to discover how you can contribute your expertise, develop new skills and help deliver practical solutions for clients and communities. Register now!

Posted by Brianna Morgan at 10:17 am

October 29, 2026

SCS Engineers 2026 company announcement graphic
SCS Engineers Announcement – Landfill Advice Useful Throughout North America

 

EPA enforcement chief Jeffrey Hall is developing a compliance-focused framework intended to improve clarity, consistency, efficiency, accountability, and federal-state coordination. Public reporting suggests the emerging framework may standardize inspections, enforcement procedures, penalty calculations, case tracking, and consent-decree reviews across EPA regions. [EPA] [InsideEPA]

Implications for the Waste Sector

Although the framework does not specifically address the waste management industry, particularly landfill owners and operators, regulated facilities could face more consistent inspections and penalty calculations, more predictable enforcement processes, and closer review of compliance obligations. [EPA] [EPA] [EPA]

Will States Cooperate?

State cooperation is likely to be conditional rather than uniform. States may support clearer expectations, shared tools, and improved coordination, but could resist changes that expand EPA headquarters’ control or reduce state discretion. The Environmental Council of the States (ECOS) policy maintains that authorized states should remain the primary implementers of inspections and enforcement and that EPA should consult states before initiating federal action. Cooperation therefore appears more likely on consistency and coordination than on measures perceived to override state authority. [ECOS]

The EPA defers to authorized states and tribes as primary implementers of federal environmental laws (such as the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act), intervening directly only under specific criteria like emergencies, multi-state issues, or unaddressed significant violations. [EPA]

 

Consider getting ahead of EPA’s push for enforcement consistency expected in 2027 with a federal, state, local compliance audit. Continue following SCS Engineers blogs, articles, and social media channels. We’ll keep you advised!

 

 

 

 

Posted by Diane Samuels at 6:00 am

October 12, 2026

For projects to be sustainable, they must be economically viable; that’s where Ann Gibbs helps.

 

Ann Gibbs has joined SCS Engineers as a Senior Project Professional in the firm’s Sustainable Materials Management (SMM) practice. She brings more than six years of experience in the solid waste, recycling, and sustainability sectors, strengthening SCS’s capabilities in strategic planning, data analytics, and financial modeling.

Before joining SCS Engineers, Gibbs served as a Project Manager and Senior Data Analyst for an economic research and consulting firm, where she managed consulting and grant-funded projects for municipal, utility, and state-level clients. Her experience includes financial and rate-setting models, program cost forecasting, waste diversion analyses, and long-term sustainability planning.

“We are very excited to have Ann join our team,” said Senior Vice President Michelle Leonard. “Our clients expect data-driven rate structures, reliable cost forecasts, improved recycling and organics programs, reduced contamination, and practical long-term sustainability plans tailored to their communities, enhanced by her financial expertise.”

Her previous work includes an organics management planning initiative for the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment that identified major diversion potential, compost demand possibly five times current production, and needs for infrastructure, education, markets, and coordinated policy; it later informed a state organics-diversion study and toolkit.

She also worked with the prestigious Environmental Research and Education Foundation on a contamination-reduction and recycling-system improvement strategy to benefit communities nationwide.

“I’m excited and grateful to join SCS and the SMM team,” said Ann Gibbs. “From day one, I’ve been impressed by how welcoming and collaborative the SCS team has been. I look forward to learning from the company’s deep expertise while helping communities of all sizes achieve their sustainability goals through practical planning, financial analysis, and sustainable solutions.”

 

 

Posted by Diane Samuels at 4:40 pm

October 9, 2026

 

On October 8, 2026, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) signed and posted a prepublication interim final rule extending the Reporting Year 2025 deadline under the Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program (GHGRP) from October 30, 2026, to March 10, 2027.

This is an interim final rule with a public comment period until November 30, 2026.  As a published interim final rule, it is effective immediately, on October 14, 2026. SCS is actively monitoring regulatory developments and will provide updates as additional guidance becomes available.

The rule provides administrative relief, not a change in emissions requirements:

  • Landfills: Facilities reporting methane under GHGRP Subpart HH gain about four additional months to finalize 2025 emissions calculations, monitoring data, and reports.
  • Solid waste operations: Covered waste-management facilities and waste-sector suppliers receive the same extension if subject to Part 98.
  • Other industries: All GHGRP-covered sectors receive additional preparation time and can account for any EPA revisions affecting Reporting Year 2025.

The new deadline is March 10, 2027, replacing October 30, 2026. Reporting obligations remain in effect unless EPA’s final reconsideration action changes them.

As EPA continues to reassess the GHGRP, the extension gives regulated entities more time to prepare and submit their Reporting Year 2025 reports. It also provides EPA additional time to consider more than 50,000 comments received on the GHGRP Reconsideration Proposal and complete any related final action. This timing will allow affected industries to account for any revisions EPA makes for Reporting Year 2025.

EPA will hold a 45-day public comment period beginning when it publishes the interim final rule in the Federal Register. EPA has not yet announced the exact comment deadline. [EPA Notices]

To read the prepublication interim final rule and related materials, visit the Rulemaking Notices for GHG Reporting page. For questions about your specific facility or industry, please contact SCS Engineers.

 

References:

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

40 CFR Part 98 [EPA-HQ-OAR-2025- 0186; FRL-12720.2-01-OAR]

RIN 2060-AX07

EPA Rulemaking Notices for GHG Reporting

 

 

Posted by Diane Samuels at 1:57 pm

October 5, 2026

SCS Engineers will join refrigeration professionals from across the industry at the 2026 RETA-RSES National Conference, October 26 to 30 at the Caribe Royale in Orlando, Florida. The conference brings together operators, technicians, engineers, facility managers and environmental and safety professionals for technical education, professional development and industry networking.

SCS experts will lead sessions focused on refrigeration safety, management of change and practical tools for operators:

  • Gene Dumas will present a Certified Refrigeration Service Technician (CRST) session.
  • Eric Girven and Travis Weber will lead a Management of Change (MOC) workshop.
  • Bill Lape will present the SCS Hotpoint, “Demonstrating a Mass Energy Balance Tool for Operators,” highlighting a practical approach operators can use to better understand system performance.

Connect with the SCS team at RETA-RSES to exchange ideas, discuss refrigeration challenges and learn more about approaches that support safe, compliant and efficient operations.

Register now!

 

Posted by Brianna Morgan at 10:28 am

September 29, 2026

Join SCS Engineers at Booth #85 at SCANPH’s Annual Conference on October 8, 2026, at the Los Angeles Convention Center in downtown Los Angeles, CA. As Southern California’s largest regional affordable housing conference, the event brings together regulators, firms, and organizations involved in affordable housing development. Connect with more than 1,300 affordable housing thought leaders, policymakers, developers, and stakeholders from across California to explore solutions and tools that help ensure everyone in our communities has a safe place to call home. See you there.

 

Posted by Brianna Morgan at 10:50 am

September 24, 2026

Join SCS Engineers on October 6-7 in Winston-Salem for the North Carolina Environmental Conference. We are excited to support this event as a gold sponsor and will be exhibiting throughout the program. Swing by Booth 511 to say hello to our folks and learn more about our services and how we help advance environmental excellence in North Carolina.

SCS will also be hosting a panel breakout session on Tuesday, October 6, discussing “Air Permitting of Renewable Natural Gas Facilities and Landfill Energy Projects”. Moderated by David Greene, PE, our panelists, Andy Sheppard, Ryan Christman, PE, and Lucas Nachman, will be discussing the key regulatory requirements, permitting considerations and practical strategies for navigating the RNG facility air permitting process.

We look forward to connecting with you at NCEC. Register at the event site here!

 

Posted by Brianna Morgan at 2:37 pm

September 22, 2026

Michelle Leonard (top), Pete Carrico (left), and Eric Peterson (right).

 

Please join SCS Engineers in congratulating three outstanding colleagues being honored at SWANA RCon this year: Michelle Leonard, Pete Carrico, and Eric Peterson.

Michelle Leonard, Senior Vice President and National Expert in Solid Waste Planning, Recycling, and Sustainable Materials Management, will receive SWANA’s Robert L. Lawrence Distinguished Service Award, the association’s highest individual honor. Michelle’s career reflects decades of leadership in recycling, organics diversion, sustainable materials management, mentorship, and professional service.

Pete Carrico, Senior Vice President and Business Unit Director of SCS Field Services, will receive the SWANA Landfill Gas and Biogas Division Hall of Flame Award, recognizing more than 40 years of sustained contributions to landfill gas systems, operations, monitoring, troubleshooting, safety, and industry education.

Eric Peterson, PE, Vice President and Director of SCS Engineers’ Medford, New Jersey office, will receive the SWANA Landfill Gas & Biogas Technical Division Distinguished Individual Achievement Award for his long-term service, technical leadership, landfill gas recovery expertise, renewable energy work, and commitment to mentoring the next generation of professionals.

These honors reflect the depth of talent, service, and innovation across SCS Engineers and our continued commitment to helping communities and clients advance practical, sustainable solutions in solid waste, recycling, landfill gas, biogas, and resource management.

Congratulations, Michelle, Pete, and Eric. We are proud to celebrate your well-earned recognition and your lasting impact on SWANA, SCS Engineers, our clients, and the solid waste and recycling industry.

 

 

 

Posted by Diane Samuels at 6:00 am